flu immunizations
Oct. 29th, 2019 11:16 amLook at this; two entries in one day--what is this, 2008? But it's because I had two very disparate thoughts that didn't sit nicely in the same post, so here you go.
When I did a unit on vaccines with my students, almost all of them were pro-vaccine ... with the exception of the flu vaccine. Many more people were on the fence about that or were actively opposed to it. The flu vaccine has the problem of being a best guess as opposed to a sure thing in terms of how relevant and effective it'll be against whatever strains of flu happen to go around, and I bet that contributes to people's feelings. With polio or measles or whooping cough, you're talking about just one illness, and the immunization is very effective; with the flu, you're talking about lots of different types of flu, and the vaccine may or may not be that effective.
Relatedly, we've been watching (against my mild objections; I guess I can tolerate the show) Arrow on Netflix, and in one episode, a drug dealer had a plan to create a citywide market of addicts by lacing a flu vaccine with the drug, so everyone who got a flu shot became addicted. "Thanks, show; great way to play to people's fears of the flu vaccine!" I shouted at the screen--and then started thinking about how this particular flavor of suspicion feels equivalent to the fears that people in Pakistan have with regard to the polio vaccine--that a purported good thing (immunization against a harmful illness) is being used by shady actors to accomplish a nefarious purpose.
When I did a unit on vaccines with my students, almost all of them were pro-vaccine ... with the exception of the flu vaccine. Many more people were on the fence about that or were actively opposed to it. The flu vaccine has the problem of being a best guess as opposed to a sure thing in terms of how relevant and effective it'll be against whatever strains of flu happen to go around, and I bet that contributes to people's feelings. With polio or measles or whooping cough, you're talking about just one illness, and the immunization is very effective; with the flu, you're talking about lots of different types of flu, and the vaccine may or may not be that effective.
Relatedly, we've been watching (against my mild objections; I guess I can tolerate the show) Arrow on Netflix, and in one episode, a drug dealer had a plan to create a citywide market of addicts by lacing a flu vaccine with the drug, so everyone who got a flu shot became addicted. "Thanks, show; great way to play to people's fears of the flu vaccine!" I shouted at the screen--and then started thinking about how this particular flavor of suspicion feels equivalent to the fears that people in Pakistan have with regard to the polio vaccine--that a purported good thing (immunization against a harmful illness) is being used by shady actors to accomplish a nefarious purpose.